Reference Check Template for Employers: Free Form

A free reference check template for employers: consent line, 10 questions, and a 1 to 5 scorecard so every reference call takes 10 minutes and stays fair.

By ReadyATS Team · · 5 min read

A small-business manager sits at a sunlit wooden desk, talking on a phone and taking notes in a blank notebook

This reference check template gives you a consent line, employment verification, 10 questions, and a 1 to 5 scorecard for owners and managers who hire 1 to 50 people. Use the same form for every finalist so you can compare answers fairly.

A typical call takes about 10 minutes. In HireRight's 2025 Global Benchmark Report, 59 percent of North American respondents included employment verification in pre-employment screening, versus 82 percent in EMEA and 77 percent in APAC (HireRight). A structured reference check template lets a small employer confirm dates, title, and rehire answers.

See ReadyATS in action

What is a reference check template?

A reference check template is a written form with a consent line, a short verification block, a fixed question list, and a scorecard so every finalist for the same role is checked the same way. Use it after a structured job interview template, as the references step in our hiring process steps.

What is in this reference check template?

This reference check template has four parts: consent, verification, 10 questions, and a 1 to 5 score. Copy the block below and fill one form per reference. Get the candidate's written permission before you call, and tell the reference you have it. This is not legal advice. A reference check form should verify title, dates, and rehire first.

Reference check form (copy and paste)

Candidate / role / date / caller:
Consent: written permission on [date]. Told the reference: Yes / No
Reference: name, title, company, phone or email, relationship, dates you worked together
Verification: job title; employment dates; would you rehire (Yes / No / Cannot say); notes
Questions 1 to 10 (copy the list below; score each answer 1 to 5):
Notes, average score, and decision (hire, hold, or do not hire), with the evidence:

Which 10 reference check questions should you ask?

Ask these 10 reference check questions in the same order for every finalist. Keep them job-related. Skip questions about age, family, health, religion, or other protected topics. For hourly roles, follow up on shifts, attendance, and customers. For office roles, follow up on deadlines, teammates, and work quality.

  1. What was their job title, and what did they actually do day to day?
  2. What employment dates can you confirm, and how long did you work with them?
  3. Would you rehire them for a similar role? Why or why not?
  4. How reliable were they with attendance, punctuality, and the schedule they were given?
  5. Tell me about a time they handled a rush, a difficult customer, or a tight deadline.
  6. How did they take feedback or a correction?
  7. How did they work with coworkers, and with customers if that was part of the job?
  8. What was their strongest contribution on your team?
  9. What support would help them do well in the first 90 days?
  10. Is there anything else a new employer should know to help them succeed in this kind of work?

How do you score reference check answers on a 1 to 5 scale?

Score the evidence, not how warm the praise sounded. Use 1 for no real example, 3 when the example meets the need, and 5 when you hear a specific example plus judgment and a later change.

Comparison table 1: scroll horizontally or focus the table region and use the arrow keys to read every column.

Question What it verifies Red flag Score 1 to 5
1 to 2. Title and dates The resume matches the job they held Dates or title off, no explanation
3. Rehire A clear, job-related yes or no A no, a long pause, or no usable reason
4. Reliability They showed up and kept the schedule Repeated no-shows or last-minute gaps
5. Busy period They can handle pressure They froze, left the work, or blamed others
6. Feedback They can correct course They became defensive or ignored direction
7. Team and customers They worked well with people Repeated conflict they did not try to fix
8. Strength A specific contribution Only vague praise, no example
9. Early support You know how to set them up No real work habit is named
10. Other A last job-related fact A warning you cannot ignore

Add the scores, or average them if you called two references.

How many references should you call, and can you use text or email?

Call two references for each finalist, preferably recent supervisors who saw the work. Do not call a current employer unless the candidate agrees on the timing. Friends, relatives, and unnamed character contacts are weak references. Use text or email to schedule the call or collect contact details from the candidate. Use a live phone call for the check itself, so you can ask a short follow-up.

Comparison table 2: scroll horizontally or focus the table region and use the arrow keys to read every column.

Method Best use Strength Weakness
Phone The actual reference check Follow-ups and tone Needs a scheduled time
Email A written record when a call cannot be set Dates and title in writing Short, polished answers
Text Scheduling, or a yes or no confirm of a time Fast Too thin for the 10 questions; use only with consent

Keep a person on the call.

How can ReadyATS help you keep reference checks consistent?

ReadyATS keeps the job, interview notes, and scorecard in one place, while a person still places the reference calls and makes the hire decision. After you use a job interview template, store this form with the candidate record. Maya does not place reference calls and does not reject anyone on an AI score.

Basic is $199 per month. No long-term commitment, cancel anytime. See ReadyATS pricing and ATS for small business.

Starting ReadyATS in 15 min Now

FAQ

What should a reference check template include?

A reference check template should include a consent line, a verification block for dates, title, and rehire, 10 job-related questions, and a 1 to 5 scorecard.

How many references should I ask for?

Two work references, preferably recent supervisors. Call both.

Is a reference check legally required?

U.S. federal law does not generally require one for every hire. This is not legal advice.

Can I check a reference by text?

Use text to schedule the call or collect contact details from the candidate. Use a live call for the 10 questions when you can.

Should I check references before or after the offer?

Many small employers check after interviews and before, or as a condition of, the offer. This is not legal advice.

References

Last checked and fetched November 21, 2026: HireRight, 2025 Global Benchmark Report (survey fielded Feb. 11 to March 9, 2025, 1,114 complete and partial responses globally); ReadyATS pricing.